View Full Version : Favorite Season
harmony2k66
February 27th, 2004, 02:39 AM
Does anyone else think that Season Four was the best? I personally loved it! I thought it was a great improvement over Season Three and all it's scatter. Don't get me wrong, I have loved every season, but something about Four really stuck out to me. It was the most unique of the four, and you could tell the writers were really trying something different. Plus, people complain about The Season Finale of Three, but when Whitecaps airs, we have the biggest Finale, probably bigger than the predictable death of Big Pussy in Two, (which was great, but didn't compare to Whitecaps for me). At first vieweing I obviously disliked the episode Christopher, but on second vieweing I thought it was just as good as the rest. This season to me, was like Chase went from Army Of One, and made a whole season out of it. IE, that momentum and pacing. And I thought that it was very deliberately paced, and was nessecary for further stories to unfold in the following seasons. Chase even said, sometimes, its more important to give an audience what they need and not what they want. Anyway, if anyone agrees with this, please post or something.
</p>
EDIT - I have added a poll to vote for each of the six seasons. I included 6a and 6b together given the numbering scheme provided by David Chase. DH.
Rightfielder21
February 27th, 2004, 06:07 AM
My order would be - 2,1,3,4
</p>
harmony2k66
February 27th, 2004, 09:23 PM
REASON SEASON FOUR WAS MY FAVIORITE
(I apologize, Im a bit scatterbrain here, but I hurt my back and the medicine they have me on has me a little out of it)
From the first moments of the Season Premiere, ?All Debts Public and Private?, to the Bergman-esque finale, ?Whitecaps?, viewers were aware that Season Four of the hit Family Drama, ?The Sopranos? would be giving us something different in the fourth season.
Creator David Chase let us know fresh off the bat that this season would be more about Tony?s marriage with Carmella, and less about the Mob. Many viewers still cite Season Four as their least favioirite, yet I thought this was the season?s most artistic. Chase has often stated that he hoped the Sopranos could enchant others the way foreign films did for him at a young age. This season carried through, and had a magnificent payoff. Season Three was more about introducing characters, only to throw them out before episodes end. Plot lines were open, and left unresolved. The simply argument by Chase and Co, was that it mirrored real life, by making it less TV. Yet the psychology, while lacking in the sense of Tony and Melfi, was all about it with Tony.
This season was all about Tony?s impulse control. His lack there of it, would later cost him his ?ducks? as his family flew away from him. The ducks were mentioned again, in ?For All Debts, Pulic And Private?, and Tony?s preparation for feeding them worked perfectly. It provided a perfect opportunity for Tony to have a hiding place, in the duck feed, from his wife Carmella. The season?s finale was hinted at it in the opening episode, when Melfi, thought Tony was talking about ?trusting only family?, and Tony was still more business-centric than family oriented.
In the episode, ?No Show?, we got Tony and Meadow on par again. Something we had been waiting for since ?College?. It was well worth the wait. The season also focused on Christopher?s drug use, as we finally tries to square away the loose ends of Chris always using. Probably the most evolving character on television, Christopher has gone from a stubborn insubordinate drug addict, to a little verion, of the cold hard, captain of industy type. The show also seemed to say goodbye to all the time they have spent on Anti Italian Defamation Leagues, in one of the show?s funniest outings. Christopher, which seemed to be everyone?s least faviorite, was rich in humor, and acted as a conduit to ?The Legend Of Tenesse Moltisanti?. The Weight was a rich throwback to the days of Season One, with junior and Tony almost going to war over psychiatry and cunninlingus. Yet this time we saw Ralphie Cifferato, and Johnny Sack, both almost getting killed over brash decisions. We saw how bad blood, and little things, would almost get a guy ?whacked?.
Episode Five, "Pie O My" was exceptional as well, if not for the humor, (Junior stealing fifty cents from Merv), then Janice muscling in on Bobby. And finally, we get to see Bobby do something besides act as comic relief. The scene with Tony and Pie at the end was classic as well.
Episode Six, ?Whoever Did This? was miles ahead of the show. While some of the Artie sub-plot might have seemed tedious, it made perfect sense. The show was perfect, and as far as psychology was concerned, it was perfect. Tony, not wanting to be an ogre, Tony, not wanting to be ?toxic?. All the psychology in this episode was some of the most realistic interpretations of someone?s psyche that the show has ever presented. Especially Jennifer Melfi, being able to hold herself against, ?The Loomer?.
?Watching Too Much Television? was exceptional. An old nod to ?46 Long?. When just the smallest thing, set Tony off. His attack of Zellman at the end, was a perfect example of why this show is so rich. Hell, Zellerman told Maurice, "Sometimes I feel like I should be punished". Guess he got what he thought he deserved. No easy answers, no explanations, and hell, who could forget the soundtrack. The Chi-Lites, and a song that is often overused in film, finally felt like it was written exactly for the scene.
"Mergers and Aquisitions" marked a turning point in the battle between Tony and Carmella. Everything was starting to make a little more sense, or as Artie Bucco would have said, "The cobwebs are now clear". The fingernail, Ralph's bottoming from the top, Valentina, Tony's boredom, and need to get himself into some more trouble. Paulie's Mother and a return to Greengrove was a nice trip down memory lane as well.
This season was finally about the growth of Carmella Soprano. No longer, the loving mob housewife, we finally saw some growth in her character. Janice and Bobby even worked. A lot of viewers complained about this sub-plot in general, yet it seems to have been laying the groundwork for whats to come in Season Five. As with Junior?s Altheimers, which was hinted at in Episode 9, ?Whoever Did This?, and the sad fate of Justin Cifferato, and the loss of Tony's top earner, or pointman, Ralphie Cifferato, seemed to be a lot of peoples favioirite of the season. I enjoyed this episode but found it to be the best when we got to spend time with Tony and Chris bonding.
The "Strong Silent Type" was awesome. Funny, dramatic, and the final nails before the coffin was shut on la marriage Soprano. Just the scene where Tony is going off on Chris for Cozzete, and the brief look between Furio and Benny, (I thought it was about everyone knowing that Tony killed Ralphie, and the look was, "He's at it again", about Tony being pissed at someone for killing an animal). This episode bore the brunt, or served to get Tony out of Melfi's office.
Episode 11, ?Calling All Cars?. It made perfect sense that Tony would walk away from therapy. He had become charmed by a ?tough? woman (Svletna), as he saw it, and viewed his therapy as a waste of time. This also hinted at Tony?s lack of impulse control. On a spur of the moment, one night stand, Tony walks out of therapy, because he believes that he is doing nothing more than bitching and whining about his problems. We get to meet Carmine Jr, who was if nothing more, giving the opportunity to deliver one of the more humorous lines of the season about a certain finance minister. The chaotic dreams, be it the opening ?Smokey Robinson? going chaotic?, or the creepy one with Tony being the hard class Italian worker, and seeing that creepy image of that woman on the stairs. I thought one of the funniest moments of the season, occurred when Tony was out in the patio in Florida, no longer in therapy, and having to deal with a nightmare. Especially the use of The Beach Boys, "Surfing, USA".
?Eloise? offered one of the more disturbing images of the season, since Ralphie beat Tracee, when Paulie smothered that old woman, all because she made fun of his mom. Which I guess stated the question again, ?Is everything, really all about everyone?s mother?. Furio?s flight was perfect, and was the most realistic way to end the Carmella, Furio crush. In my opinion, Furio, who realized, that he almost threw Tony into a helicopter blade, in a bout of extreme jealousy, knew he had no other choice but to leave the country.
And of Course, Whitecaps, with ?Scenes From A Marriage? undertones, was perfect. The Woody Allen film, "Interiors" also came to mind. Johny Sack and Tony?s ending over the aborted whacking of Carmine, seems to be the most mob centric ending, or at least realistic one possible. In my opinion, this episode was perfect. It was by far, my faviorite episode of The Sopranos. I viewed the season as being all about Tony, and his lack of impulse control. He agreed to to whack Carmine because of cash problems. Cash that was obviously neseccary to continue to provide for his family. In ?Eloise?, Tony realized what Sack wanted and said it best, ?Holy S***?. But by the beginning of ,?Whitecaps?, Tony had realized It wasn?t the best decision. Yet he continued with it because he needed the extra money if he was going to by ?Whitecaps?. As soon as Carmella was no longer with him, and Carmine had settled. Tony finally exerted impulse control. I think this episode, like ?Army Of One? was for Season Four?, has all the neseccary implements, for what will occur in the next season. Tony is very good at what he does. Give or take, Ralph, and a few other decisions. He realized, that the only reason he was agreeing with the hit on Carmine, was because of the money he needed for Carmella. Now, Tony might not be doing too good when Season Five opens, but I would be willing to bet that by ?All Due Respect? he will be back on top. Anyway, sorry about the lengthy post, but this was my opinion on why Season Four was the best.
</p>Edited by: <A HREF=http://pub132.ezboard.com/bsopranolandforum.showUserPublicProfile?gid=harmon y2k66>harmony2k66</A> at: 2/28/04 6:57 am
Sopranogirl
February 27th, 2004, 10:33 PM
I agree that season 4 was great. But I am partial to Season 2. In S1 we got to know the family, S2 we got to see inside the Family Business. I think Tony was at his height of control and it was a "Very Good Year"
Although I love all the seasons S3 was not my favorite. There were some good episodes, but the storyline with Meadow at college and her relationship with her roommate was tedious, and Jackie Aprille Jr had to go because he was such a wannabe that probably wouldn't ever have the brains to make in his Dad's business.
</p>
harmony2k66
February 27th, 2004, 11:45 PM
I agree with you Sopranogirl, the more I watch Season Three, the more I don't enjoy it as much as the rest. A lot of fans who were pissed about Four, (every single character not getting whacked, Tony not whacking Carmella, Tony not wacking Furio, Tony not wacking....etc....etc....etc....) like Three a lot. I still love Three, I just thought that it was all over the place. Jackie Jr was a pain, and if that rumor is true, the one about him working at Applebee's, I would not be suprised. I rented Season One again, and plan to watch it. I don't know why, But I think a lot of Five might be Tony, "taking care of business", and six going to back to Season One. I see the show ending with Tony still a mob boss, and life, just going on. The again, we got a long time till 2006!
</p>
TheSopranosHBO
March 1st, 2004, 04:41 PM
My favorites are 2,3,1,4.....but that will ALL Change when Season 5 is said an done with......Less than a week til the epic continues!
</p>
BadaBingBubba
March 1st, 2004, 11:53 PM
My order would be: 2,3,1,4. Season 4 kinda started out slow but picked up toward the end of the season.
</p>
Zillajay23
March 4th, 2004, 12:49 AM
I can't believe that nobody has season one as their favorite, that is by far my favorite. It was so fresh and entertaining I love the first season. I have worn out my DVD's for all the Sopranos but the first season is the most worn. If I were to rate them it would be. 1,3,2,4 although I love every season. Season one seemed to play out as just one long movie, and never really strayed. Although college was very unique and stand alone, I still believe the first season stayed on course the best. Season 3 had the most intense episodes, with Universtiy, and Employee of the Month. Like I said they all are great I just thought more people would pick the first season it was brilliant.
</p>
Detective Hunt
May 17th, 2007, 07:25 PM
I've stickied this thread and pollified it, thinking members might want to cast their vote officially, as it were. As noted in the first post, I've included the first and second part of season six together since that's the way Chase numbered them. If anyone thinks they should be separate, let me know quick so we don't mess up the polling numbers.
Have fun. :icon_mrgreen:
FlyOnMelfisWall
May 17th, 2007, 08:11 PM
Good idea, DH. I'm gonna wait until the end of this season like a good juror.:icon_biggrin:
WhistlingInTheWheatfield
May 19th, 2007, 01:21 PM
I would give the nod to season 1 slightly over season 5 as my favorite. Everything was fresh and new in season 1 and we were able to watch the characters develop and make our own opinions about them. 5 was also special to me, the infusion of new characters (Tony B., Phil Leotardo, Feech) added a new dynamic to everything. Also the building of the conclusion of Adriana's arc and the rebuilding of the relationship with Tony and Carmela. A lot of memorable eps in this season.
AJColossal
May 19th, 2007, 02:58 PM
I'm waiting for the ending of these episodes, but I think it's going to end up being six for me.
My final order will probably be: 6,2,5,1,4,3.
Zultan
June 9th, 2007, 02:11 PM
My order would go 1(10/10),2(10/10),4(9/10),3(9/10),5(8/10),6(7/10).
Season 6 has been the worse for me, because in 6a they took half the season to deal with Vito's changes and how he was forced to come out, yet in 6b the character development had been pretty bad, Tony randomly gets a massive gambling addictiong, and the ralathionship between him and Hesh isn't really good? all that was in ONE ep. Also, Melfi, how she reacted to what happened in the dinner party could be stretched out a few eps.
Oh, and then theres Chris, he could have been given a better time.
Reasons for 5 being so low, considering it has such fantastic eps in Two Tonys, Rat Pack, Test Dream, Long Tern,,was that it had blatent filler eps, In Camelot was horrid, and the episode where Tony and Ade were "together" was so badly done, considering everyone forgot about it next ep :/
JonnySoprano
June 9th, 2007, 05:20 PM
my favourite seasons are as follows:
season 1 - meet tony soprano, never in tv history has a programme instantly had me gripped from the get-go as this one. The pilot is a masterpiece the way Tony personally introduce's us to his friends and life through his visit to Melfi. The whole season is brilliant with the exception of ''a hit is a hit'' which still has some brilliant comedy moments - chris playin guitar on ad's ex's head!
season 4 & season 2 - I cant seperate these despite them being total opposites. Both had great episodes, whoever did this, whitecaps, funhouse, from where to eternity. Season 2 is the season i re-watch the most, big girls dont cry, the happy wanderer another 2 good episodes i basically enjoy the whole season and the montauge at the start and end of the season is for me 2 of the best musical moments of the series. Season 4 i enjoy for its originality, I especially like the rise and fall of ralphie.
season 5 - this is a great season but for some reason i find it hard to put the more recent seasons at the top of the list. maybe in years to come i will view this differently. the test dream, long term parking, cold cuts are stand out episodes from this season and this is also the start of tonys downfall - a lot of what happens this season is the begining of the end.
This then leaves me with season 6 - im not placing this last, im gonna wait until sunday to make my final decision but i feel that this season is almost perfect. i feel the season would be much stronger without filler=type episodes, im embarrased to call a soprtanos episode ''filler'' but i cant think of any other word. something of importance/relevance happens in nearly every episode but i would have liked less vito scenes, and didnt like fleshy part of the thigh and the ride. stand out would be join the club, members only, kaisha, cold stones, all of season 6 part 2 - i think chase has really done the business, i cant pick any fault except for the ep with vitos son. Got to mention the moments between Tony & Chris - not the killing, the scene in the church with Chickentown playing- magnificent.
PFloyd69
June 10th, 2007, 05:33 PM
I agree with a lot of what JohnnySoprano said.
Season 1 is still my favorite. The Pilot, College, Isabella, I dream of Jeannie Cusamano, and Pax Soprana are all top notch episodes in my mind. episodes like Boca, 46 long, and Meadowlands are just a notch below. This season is great at finding a balance between the two families and the amount of airtime given to each one. Classic TV.
Season 2 is next for me. Again, great episodes this season from beginning to end. I like this season more and more as i re-watch it. Early on this wasn't one of my favorite seasons but it has climbed the ladder. From where to eternity and Knight in white satin armor are amazing eps. Funhouse is a very thorough and entertaining season finale (i love the music montage at the end).
Season 4-After seasons 1 and 2 its hard for me to put them in to order but i'll give season 4 the nod over 3 and 5. Great opener BTW. I did NOT like the Carmella-Furio love story but the rest of the season is solid. I really liked the work of Joey Pants in this season. Chris's drug habits and Junior's trial also made for interesting moments. Bobby starts to become more of a focal point in the series. They show a different side of the mob. Not as many great eps. as 1 and 2, but a solid season overall.
Season 3- This series drops in rank IMO because of a rather weak (relatively) opener and finale. They just didn't do it for me. Pine Barrens, To save us all from satans power, and others were good episodes. I just didn't buy Jackie Jr. as a main storyline. Also i was very disinterested in Meadow's relationships. Again there were some standout eps. that will go down in Soprano history, but as a whole the seaosn wasn't one of the top one to me.
Season 5- Now most people who I've talked to love this season. Not me. I didn't hate it by any means but i didn't love it either. This is last to me as of now. Like season 2 though, it could change in time.
With season 5 i wasn't crazy about the Tony B storyline. Okay we get it, Tony's love for Tony B stems from feelings of insecurity and basically selfishness. This was no great revelation for me. I got sick and tired of Tony and Carm's separation after a while. I DID like some of the Melfi scenes, Johnny Sac becomming boss, the tension with NY, and the resolution of Adrianna's role. In the end though i think Tony was as unlikeable in this season as any and that hurt it IMO. And, again, the separation and Tony B storylines that i wasn't thrilled about. Still great TV, better than anything else on, but not my favorite when comparing it to other Soprano seasons. I won't call it worst but least favorite. Let me say though that Long Term Parking, Test Dream, and Irregular Around the Margins were very good eps.
I'll wait for season 6 to finish before i rank that, but i think it will end up being one of my favorites. Probably up there with 1 and 2.
bigbadbill007
June 23rd, 2007, 05:58 PM
Season one for me. the plots about his mob life and family life were great. The mob part has always been great but tonys family have really started to anoy me over the final few seasons. carmella been great but AJ and Meadow have really got on my nerves
AJ WAS great when he was younger. a real little rebel
All the seasons were entertaining for me but some were rather slow and short of explosive action. season 2 started very slow but ended great (thats why it makes my top 3). season 6 started great but disapointed us at the end. It was the sopranos at its worst
seasons 7, 5 and 1 were great throughout. I really liked seasons 3 and 4 unlike some. they were short of action but provided some great and amusing storylines in tony's two lives. Pine barrons was probably my best episode ever
here is my rankings of the seaons:
Season 1
Season 7
season 2
season 3
Season 5
season 4
seaosn 6
Irishwiseguy
October 28th, 2007, 08:17 PM
Season one for me. the plots about his mob life and family life were great. The mob part has always been great but tonys family have really started to anoy me over the final few seasons. carmella been great but AJ and Meadow have really got on my nerves
AJ WAS great when he was younger. a real little rebel
All the seasons were entertaining for me but some were rather slow and short of explosive action. season 2 started very slow but ended great (thats why it makes my top 3). season 6 started great but disapointed us at the end. It was the sopranos at its worst
seasons 7, 5 and 1 were great throughout. I really liked seasons 3 and 4 unlike some. they were short of action but provided some great and amusing storylines in tony's two lives. Pine barrons was probably my best episode ever
here is my rankings of the seaons:
Season 1
Season 7
season 2
season 3
Season 5
season 4
seaosn 6
I think season 6 part 1 and 2 should just be counted as season 6. No season 7
SilvioMancini
January 6th, 2008, 03:51 PM
Without a doubt Season 6, both halves.
Amazing storytelling and writing unparallelled in the history of the television medium IMHO. Every episode is written to weave itself into a previous episodes details or an episode to come. Season Six was the master version of this. Because it used all prior five seasons plus the new material to create the full circle effect (Onion rings anyone?) that connects the very last show to the very first. I know it took them two years to come up with it. TWO YEARS! Thats a long time for a television show to develop for just one season. I think the final season makes the entire series absolutely flawless stoytelling. And the ending just proves its genius more than ever. But I still am a sucker for Season 1. A lot of gems in there........
Irishwiseguy
January 15th, 2008, 02:13 PM
Yup, season 6 for me.
Garth
March 16th, 2008, 02:14 PM
Season 5 has always held a special place in my heart. Even the poorest of episodes in the fifth season (probably In Camelot, for me) has some AMAZING moments. This season just had some real jaw-droppers, and taking Tony out of the comfort of his home was a brilliant move.
Irishwiseguy
March 16th, 2008, 02:41 PM
Ya, season 5 was a brilliant season. I have seen "In Camelot" recently enough, and I thought it was a brilliant episode. A sort of nothing happens but "everything" happens episode.
Ps; Is it not odd that harmony2k66 said his favorite season was season 4, but yet there is no votes for season 4.
jouster
March 18th, 2008, 07:49 PM
This thread was made a poll well after it was created, Irish, so harmony probably didn't get a chance to vote.
Personally I think, episode for episode, season six was the best, with a very strong front end and an even stronger back end (with a bit of a sag in the middle), but for my favorite season I went with season five, for much the same reason Garth gave.
Murasaki
March 26th, 2008, 07:47 PM
Season 4 was my dad's favorite season as well.
But I'd have to say my favorite season was Season 1. There are many things about the series that makes it truly great, but perhaps my favorite part of the show was the dynamic between Tony and Melfi. In the first season, Melfi served as both a prominent character and a conflict driving the plot, as well as a means for us to hear Tony's thoughts and feelings. Later in the series, while she's still a good character, she's not nearly as integral to the story line and we don't see as much of her, which I think is unfortunate.
Melfi's not the only reason Season 1 was my favorite, though. I thought it was nicely self-contained and had a clear over-arching plot. I didn't feel these aspects were quite as evident in future seasons (and pretty much non-existent in Season 3).
I should mention, though, I thought all off the seasons were outstanding. :)
JLTucker
January 2nd, 2009, 12:19 AM
My favorite season is season six, mainly due to the opening minutes of the season, the episode "Mayham", and "The Blue Comet", which I find are both works of art.
BFazioCriminalMastermind
July 11th, 2011, 01:28 PM
Favorite Beatles album? Favorite Sopranos season? Same type of real tough question but I would have to say I have an answer, and the answer is SEASON 5. Despite crucial characters such as Richie or Ralphie no longer being onboard mind you. When the season first began and I knew that Buscemi was going to be on I at first didn't think it was going to work out being that he was already known for so many other things prior. Was I ever wrong for I think of his 'Tony B' character first and foremost whenever I do think of Season 5 like I'm sure many others do. His whole transformation from trying to be a 'citizen' to 'going back' on the episode which I think is the centerpiece of the whole season, 'Marco Polo' (best part when Carm calls out her mother on her 'self-loathing') and yet another example of good music being put to good use ('Bad N Ruin' by the Faces). The character Feech and the tension between he and Tony not a bad substitute for Richie/Ralphie if however brief, 'The Test Dream' ep being to Sopranos what I guess 'Revolution #9' is to the Beatles and then who can forget the 2nd last ep when we see the LAST OF Adrianna, arguably the most significant character ever on the show. And then of course in the finale where Tony has to, pretty much, beat Phil to-the-punch with Tony B, the still-animosity between both he and NY for handling it that way, that interesting ending running from the feds in the snow, children singing in the nearby elementary school (someone fill me in on the symbolism behind it if there is any), etc. It's simply the season I find myself going back to the most whenever I watch Sopranos re-runs which I tend to still do quite habitually.
BobbyBacala
December 21st, 2011, 06:03 PM
Season Six for me. I just think it started out strong and never let up. I especially like Season Six Part 2. Those final nine episodes are probably the best run of the series in my opinion.
vBulletin® v3.6.5, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.